Kubatana.net ~ an online community of Zimbabwean activists

A buffoon, is he?

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Posted on March 8th, 2010 by Delta Ndou. Filed in Media, Reflections, Uncategorized, Women's issues.
5 comments filed

President Jacob Zuma has been called all sorts of names of late for making the choice to enjoy the privilege of being a polygamist which his culture permits, which the South African constitution does not criminalize and which the women he is married to have accepted much to public outrage.

While I have strong personal feelings against polygamy, I notice that during the hullabaloo that ensured – none of Zuma’s wives voiced dissent, none of them took to the streets in protest over their husband’s perpetual marriages, engagements and never-ending wooing.

It was to me, a case of the media crying louder than the bereaved – for if indeed there are any who are harmed or aggrieved by how Zuma conducts his love-life; surely it would be the women he has married, promised to marry and those he has fathered children with – all of whom have remained silent. The silence, presumably, of those who are in acquiescence.

But then people are entitled to their opinions, moreso if the opinions they wish to voice regard those who are in positions of power, who find themselves accountable to the public and whose private lives play out in the public domain as Zuma’s life has.

Now the British media called him a ‘buffoon’ who also happened to be ‘over-sexed’. Now to my way of thinking, buffoon is not high on the scale as far as insults go – in fact it is really nothing compared to some of the colorful invectives that have gone Zuma’s way.

Inadvertently, this insult has done more to turn the tide of public opinion in favor of Zuma, primarily because it was uttered by a white man, who happens to be non-African and whose contemptuous view of Zuma’s polygamous status has riled the afrocentric and pan-africanist sensibilities of some of us.

Though it may sound clichéd, Zuma’s conduct has a cultural premise – an African culture, which (whatever its flaws and imperfections may be) is our proud heritage and an integral part of our ethos as a people, as continent and as a race.

Where I come from, when we fight or disagree – we are allowed to do so without pulling punches knowing that what binds us is greater than what would divide us. I have often found that the only thing that quenches a family feud is the intrusion of an outsider, one who would presume to appoint themselves as the judge and proceed to proffer unsolicited advice or opinions on what is an internal affair.

And that British man has managed to raise my hackles by his superciliousness and the nauseating superiority complex that informs his interpretation of African customs, specifically polygamy.

Had he desired to make an informed judgment of President Zuma’s lifestyle, he would have done so within the confines of the African customs and culture that permits him to be a polygamist.

Anyone, particularly a non-African, would do well to show the appropriate level of humility that is reflective of his or her limited experience and knowledge of African mores when they make the choice to hazard an opinion. Logic dictates that it be so.

Voltaire once stated, I do not agree with what you have to say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it. It is in the same vein that I am compelled to leap to Zuma’s defense; for while I (as an African) do not agree with how he chooses to conduct his life (and find polygamy to be unpalatable) I defend without qualms his right to marry many women as our culture permits and in the same breathe I would be duty-bound to defend the right of all his wives to be married to their one polygamous husband.

It is a personal choice they have made and whatever the consequences – it is not my place to hurl insults at them because I happen not to agree with the decisions grown, mature and adult women have made in picking a life partner.

So much for the gospel of tolerance that the has been preached by the West with advent of fighting for gay rights the world over and here is one who would scorn a man for marrying three women and find it palatable that two men ‘jump’ each other’s bones?

Whatever; that snide remark however goes beyond the issue of Zuma because really the issue is polygamy and polygamy is an African issue and surely any disparaging comment made about it reflects on the African people whose culture makes it permissible?

A buffoon, is he? What does that make the rest of us, I wonder? Or would someone care to explain how that remark has nothing to do with the rest of us; sons, daughters, brothers, sisters, aunts and cousins of polygamists – let me guess – we’re just a family of African ‘buffoons’.

Text message threats

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Posted on March 5th, 2010 by Bev Clark. Filed in Activism, Governance, Media, Uncategorized.
Comments Off

Zimbabwe civic organisations ZimRights and Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights (ZLHR) recently issued a joint statement drawing attention to the rising repression directed at human rights defenders in this country.

The statement says that various members of the ZimRights board have received threatening text messages.

ZimRights and ZLHR also said:  “We urge the inclusive government and particularly the co-Home Affairs Ministers and the Police Commissioner-General to unequivocally guarantee the safety of all these human rights defenders and to assure them of their security pending full investigations into the alleged threats.”

Here are some of the text messages:

Nunurai Jena, ZimRights Regional Chairperson for Mashonaland West received a message saying, “If we give you a task to ask your ZimRights colleagues to slow down and forget about the constitution making process will you do that or else…? Just comply.”

Chitungwiza regional chairperson, Netsai Kaitano’s message read, “Chipositori nekodzero, kana matongerwo enyika zvinopindirana papi? (How are apostolic faith and rights or politics linked?) Have you forgotten the pain of those beatings. Bidi and Tsunga are gone, Pelagia, Ok, Phulu and Tshuma won’t be there anymore, when we will come for you.”

Jabulisa Tshuma, the organisation’s treasurer’s message said, “Mr Treasurer Tshuma, who are your sponsors? You are all over the country. Are you turning ZimRights into a political party? What is the motive of your donors?”

Please get in touch with ZimRights and send them a message of solidarity.

And while these abuses take place under the Government of National Unity, the MDC is responsible for them. Email the MDC on mdc.internationalrelations@gmail.com and ask them to demand a full investigation.

Love thy neighbour

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Posted on March 5th, 2010 by Amanda Atwood. Filed in Uncategorized.
Comments Off

A recent blog post by Anglican Information shares a letter from Paul Magaso in Harare. In it, Magaso discusses the split in the Anglican church in Harare – and attributes it to a divided opinion on homosexuality. Magaso expresses concern for those who “sympathise with homosexuals,” and reports that “The Diocese of Harare, after a lengthy debate during the Synod, put forth a bold statement enshrined within an Act, that there would be no acceptance of homosexuality or lesbianism within the church, since it went contrary to the scriptures.”

But, like the email that Bev Clark shared last week points out, selective application of what is, and isn’t contrary to scripture abounds. Meanwhile, an adherence to “scripture” shrouds a fear and intolerance that violates Jesus’ most basic commandments: Love God (not scripture, God). And love your neighbour.

More birthday gift suggestions

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Posted on March 4th, 2010 by Amanda Atwood. Filed in Governance, Uncategorized.
Comments Off

For Mugabe’s birthday we asked subscribers what gift they thought he should give to Zimbabwe. Responses have continued to come in, with retirement – and civil servants salaries – as the most popular suggestions. Here is some more of what people had to say:

  • Retirement letter.
  • THE OLD MAN SHOULD JUST RETIRE AND GIVE OTHERS A CHANCE
  • He should retire
  • Goodbye Zimbabwe i quit.
  • The best he can give
  • Civil servant salaries
  • Cde President is going to offer us nothing good yesterday
  • The gift is Mugabe must increase civil servants salary tired of paying incetives
  • Act  on  allows  and  salaries  for  civil  servants
  • Let him cushion the civil service.
  • Mugabe should give back Zimbabwe  to the people as a bday present.
  • Birthday gift – taking a final break and deserved rest.
  • One act of kindness
  • A new beggining to zim and let the young stars rule
  • The greatest gift to the people would to fully implement GPA and for put the interests of Zimbabwe first and ZANU(PF)’s.
  • Mugabe should give Zimbabweans a special gift of leaving the office!
  • HE SHOULD RESIGN AD CAL 4 ELECTIONS. O GIVE PRESIDENT TSVANGIRAI OTHORITY 2 LED E NATION 4 HIS SAFE EXIT. MORE INFO ON POLITICAL
  • Mugabe have  to give  his position to Tsvangirai as a gift to Zimbabwe.
  • His retirement
  • HE WIL GIVE POVERTY AND DESPAIR
  • Mugabe will give us   suffering  and hunger. M D C dont  lay us  down we  trust you! you  are   the  angels of  us we support you thank you.
  • Mugabe should give a resignation letter 2 Zimbabweans as a gift
  • He must step down…
  • Resigination is the only present we need from Bob.
  • Mugabe must give us his resignation today
  • The greatest gift to the people would to fully implement GPA and for once put the interests of Zimbabwe first and ZANU(PF)’s last.
  • To resign or give civil servants ngoda & better salaries
  • He should give back the legimate winner  of 2008 election
  • Give the country to others he is old enough
  • His farewell speech!
  • Mugabe should just QUIT his position as president & admit TOTAL FAILURE.this would be the best gift he can ever give to the suffering Zimbabweans.
  • Freedom
  • RESIGNATION LETTER
  • The gift packet should have freedom
  • The president shld give Zim a budget for the construction of roads and fixture of water pipes. Thank you.
  • HE  SHOULD  SAY  PUBLIC  I  HAVE  WALKED   MY  JNY WELL. ‘ NOW   ITS  MY  TIME  TO  REST ‘
  • He should give democracy to zim
  • Retirement
  • He should leave the office  for retering (step down) he is old  (dhokoza remunhu) mombe yakadya plastic iri nani.
  • Mugabe should assure zimbabweans that he is resigning from active politics as a matter of urgency.
  • Mugabe ìs going to iam going to gvn this cantìry til ìdie.
  • Mugabe should be given a farewell birthday wish because he has long lived enough to destroy our country
  • The best he should do for the country of Zimbabwe on his birthday’s to handover power to young
  • A gift which we are expecting from Mugabe is He must resin from the G.V.T
  • It’s only  his resignation as it worth more than a fleet of luxurious cars.
  • Apology&Resignation.
  • He should parcel out more land for agric purposes
  • Mugabe will give Zimbabweans
  • Mugabe should give a gift of a good farewell live on the national broadcaster .
  • Mugabe will offer nothing. Shd only offer  is  2  resign. Thank  you.
  • Retirement!!!
  • He shouid announce his retirement .Release  Tony Bennet and appoint him Deputy Minister of Agricultare.Fire Tomana and Gideon Gono .Have free and fair elections internationally supervised .Repeal draconian laws such as Aippa and Posa .Equal righs for Gays and Lesbians Legalize gay marriages.
  • to give power to mdc t leader
  • Resignation and Bennet please thats the gift
  • Resignation letter
  • Mgabe’s gift to Zim should be a  resignation as of y’st’ yr.
  • THE BEST GIFT ROBERT SHOULD GIVE ZIM IS TO GIVE US A REST BY RETIRING IN HIS RURAL ZVIMBA.
  • He should call it quits and give us peace of mind.
  • THE BIGGEST BIRTHDAY PRESENT FRM MUGABE TO ZIM AND THE WORLD IS FOR HIM TO STEP DOWN OR DIE .
  • The best birthday present we can get from mugabe is for him to resign ‘pronto’
  • He must gve zmbwns peace by resigning.
  • Nothing good we can expect from this old man except spending huge amount of taxpayers’money.
  • His retirment in April on the 3Oth Ind.day.
  • He should give up democracy not dictatorship
  • MUGABE MUST GAVE ZIM FREEDOM AND PEACE
  • RETIREMENT
  • Mugabe should give the nation a present of retirement on his birthday.
  • The ONLY greatest gift Old Bob can give to the people of Zimbabwe is RESIGNATION!!PERIOD.
  • The only gift mugabe should give Zimbabweans is the fulfilment of what he has signed for in the Global Political Agreement.
  • Resign and disappear from the face of this earth he has caused too much suffering
  • Resignation
  • The present dat mugabe shld gve zim is his presidency. Nothn more
  • Mugabe’s ONLY acceptable gift 2 Zimbabweans on his birthday ………. RETIREMENT
  • I THINK HE MUST GIVE US A PRESENT OF ANOUNCING HIS RETIREMENT AND CALL FOR ELECTIONS
  • Mugabe will never give Zimbawe any benefit but is eroding the contry
  • He should hav announced his resignation
  • The best present he can give Zim is to bring sanity to Zesa and telone. Their rates are  ridiculously high. A look at rentals too is long overdue. Zim 4 RESIGNING OR OWNERING ALL OUTSTANDING GPA ISSUES.
  • The best gift R.G. can give us as Zmbabweans is to resign.
  • As he approaches 90 Mr Mugabe should give back the country to the people of Zimbabwe. The Presidential chair must surely be getting uncomfortable after so long in it, let him give it back to the country and move into something more suitable to his age. It is not too late for the people to accept this gesture and in return give him the benefit of a dignified old age. This is something which he may never know if he does not reach a compromise and step down now.
  • The best Birthday present the ‘President’ should give to this country  is tell us that he is winding up his political career and Zimbabweans should prepare for a ‘difficult’ life after him and we should learn to be ‘self reliant’ because he has tried his best to ‘empower’ us. He should sign off by saying “Don’t cry for me Zimbabwe”!
  • A good gift would be to apologise for the Gukurahundi massacre
  • what i think mugabe should do as he celebrate his 86 birthday is to handover total power to Mr Richard Morgan Tsvangirai for our better future and of our kids
  • The only acceptable and appreciated gift every Zimbabwean can wish to get from this oldest dictator on the planet on his birthday is to resign
  • As he approaches 90 Mr Mugabe should give back the country to the people of Zimbabwe. The Presidential chair must surely be getting uncomfortable after so long in it, let him give it back to the country and move into something more suitable to his age. It is not too late for the people to accept this gesture and in return give him the benefit of a dignified old age. This is something which he may never know if he does not reach a compromise and step down now.

Please invalids only

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Posted on March 4th, 2010 by Amanda Atwood. Filed in Inspiration.
Comments Off

invalids_only_100304

A friend and I were walking at Borrowdale Race Course recently
(it was for a good cause!) and had a small laugh at this sign.

Kubatana.net – Technology for Transparency

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Posted on March 4th, 2010 by Amanda Atwood. Filed in Economy, Governance, Uncategorized.
Comments Off

Bev and I were interviewed last month as part of the Global Voices research project and podcast series Technology for Transparency research project. Victor Kanoga asked us some interesting questions about what we do, why we do it, and what difference it makes. It’s a bit rough and ready – we know from our experience with Inzwa how difficult it can be to accurately transcribe recorded interviews, particularly when they’re conducted over the phone. But it’s still a useful overview of our work and some of the challenges we’re facing. You can read more – and listen – here.