Kubatana.net ~ an online community of Zimbabwean activists

Archive for the 'Governance' Category

Better things to do

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Friday, June 17th, 2011 by Bev Clark

Zimbabwe’s useless Parliament. Isn’t Wednesday a golf day? You get what you vote for.

Being a Wednesday yesterday, the business of the House of Assembly was preceded by question and answer session where backbenchers quizzed Ministers about policies and programmes under their purview. Sadly, there were only three Ministers in the House during the session, namely; Deputy Prime Minister Professor Arthur Mutambara, the Minister of Finance Hon. Tendai Biti and the Minister of Public Works Hon. Joel Gabbuza. As a result, all questions with written notice were deferred. The House also debated a condolence motion on the death of Edgar Tekere.
- Excerpt from the Southern African Parliamentaru Support Trust Bulletin No 19

Talking corruption and bribery

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Monday, June 13th, 2011 by Michael Laban

Corruption is easier to define than bribery. Or, there are lot more definitions out there. Transparency International defines it “the abuse of entrusted power for private gain”.

Fairly simple. Someone has a position – which has ‘power’ to it – whether it is the check out clerk’s power to ring up your purchases, or make you stand and wait and wait and wait, or it is the passport officer, who “hasn’t got the right paper to make you a passport”, so you can choose between never travelling, or giving over some other paper.

Someone abuses that position – you must make a facilitation payment, or take them to dinner, or buy them a beer.

Bribery may be that facilitation payment (money), or anything else (gifts, information, kissing up, favours sexual or otherwise, a lift, a banana, whatever), given to someone (individual or group). Whatever is given, so long as it is not ‘official’ – so it varies with whoever gives it, it does not get receipted, and/or it is not openly asked for as part of the fee. In this respect, a tip to a waiter or barman is a bribe.

Be that as it may, it is one part of this blog investigation. Bribery may or may not be illegal. It may or may not be standard procedure. It may or may not be expected. One of the things we are curious to find is the who, what, where, when, why, of bribery. This blog investigation is not intended to be judgmental. It is simply intended to get the information out there, so people, be they visitors or local people, know how to act? How much to tip/bribe? When to do it? What is vulgar and not vulgar? When is it expected, and when is it insulting?

From Wikipedia:
Bribery, a form of corruption, is an act implying money or gift given that alters the behaviour of the recipient. Bribery constitutes a crime and is defined by Black’s Law Dictionary as the offering, giving, receiving, or soliciting of any item of value to influence the actions of an official or other person in charge of a public legal duty.

Or;
The bribe is the gift bestowed to influence the recipient’s conduct. It may be any money, good, right in action, property, preferment, privilege, emolument, object of value, advantage, or merely a promise or undertaking to induce or influence the action, vote, or influence of a person in an official or public capacity.

So, it has aspects. Something is given. All agree. That something may be quite a number of things.

Behaviour is changed (influenced). Or intended to. All agree. You want the barman to notice you and get you a beer. You want the passport officer to give you travel documents. You want the attendant to fill your bike up with petrol. You want to get your property deeds in your name. You want people to vote for you. You need your ‘free’ anti-retrovirals.

Bribery is a crime. Not all agree. But this is fine. We are not going to look at that. We just want to know what happens. How it happens. Why it happens. We want the information out there for all to see. We want examples.

For example, I was run down by a woman who drove through a red light many years ago. My bicycle went under the car, and I smashed her windscreen. With my face. I spent five days in a coma. My mother came form Australia to ‘look after’ her brain damaged son in Zimbabwe.

One activity involved going to the police for report filling, fines, bureaucracy, paper work and those exciting activities (i.e. who was responsible to pay for the brain scan, which seems to have found something). While waiting in the Police officers office, we listened to him lament (it was 1200) about his lunch that was ordered, and how would he pick it up, would we be finished so he could get it before it got cold, etc.? All good questions.

When the husband of the (obviously guilty) driver appeared, it did not go missing on him. He offered to ‘sort out’ the officer’s meal. Things went well for him then. The charge was not ‘driving with undue care’ which carried an obligatory 3 day jail sentence! They paid for treatment, dental work and a new bicycle, but no jail time.

From the examples, we want to know where the bribery happens the most. In medicine (hospitals, doctors and nurses, drugs), with the traffic police, Ministry of housing, Registrar general and travel documents, customs, local government, drivers licences, Emergency taxis and public transport, the courts, prisons, criminal police investigations, political offences, the diamond industry, or where?

We want to know “how much?” Tipping, as it is common, and most see it as legal, is easy. Ten to fifteen percent of the bill. But, how much do you ‘tip’ a ‘street kid’ (anyone of any age or sex, that inhabits the street) who offers to assist you in cheating the city of it’s parking fees? How much do you pay to ‘avoid’ a speeding ticket, after you have, in fact, been driving above the speed limit? What is the ‘fine’ with and without receipt, for not having break down triangles? How much do you pay to expedite a hospital bed? If the bed is supposed to be free, what is 10 to 15 percent?

How much is your vote worth? People offered to vote for me if I would buy them a beer. Now this is quite insulting, considering that many people (over 15 000, but the actual number is definitely unknown) died so that the ‘seller’ had the right to vote. And he was willing to sell it for a beer (maybe $1.00). And how was I to know (voting is secret) whether he voted for me anyway?

Perhaps that is why I lost the last election?

Age of some of Zimbabwe’s voters questionable

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Friday, June 10th, 2011 by Elizabeth Nyamuda

Mugabe’s Latest Gift to Zimbabwe: the Secret of Living Longer
Good news from Zimbabwe where, despite Western media reports of political crisis, economic stagnation and widespread poverty, the electoral roll indicates the country is actually one of the healthiest on earth. The October 2010 count finds 41,100 voters in Zimbabwe aged 100 or more – four times the number of centenarians in Britain, whose population is more than five times as large. Another 132,500 Zimbabwean voters are in their 90s; 16,800 Zimbabwean voters are also 110 years old, all of them, amazingly, born on New Year’s Day in 1901. Read more

Action on Zimbabwe in South Africa

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Thursday, June 9th, 2011 by Bev Clark

A call to action from Zimbabwe Solidarity Forum:

March & Mass Rally for a Clear SADC Roadmap to Zimbabwe Elections

Saturday, 11 June 2011

From Sandton Park to Sandton Convention Centre
09:00-13:00hrs

YOUR PICK UP POINT & TIME:
CONTACT: +27735211813, +27722389192, +27726393795

SPEAKERS FROM: Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition, Zimbabwe Exiles Forum, Zimbabwe Solidarity Forum, Global Zimbabwe Forum, National Constitutional Assembly, Southern African Women’s Institute on Migration Affairs, COSATU, South African Council of Churches, Swaziland Democracy Campaign, Zimbabwe Treason Trialist Solidarity Committee & others…

Mugabe and the White African

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Thursday, June 9th, 2011 by Bev Clark

From the BBC web site

After the success of his documentary film, Mugabe and the White African, British-born Ben Freeth has become one of Zimbabwe’s best-known white farmers. He has now published a book of the same name, chronicling his family’s fight, in the face of violent attacks, to keep hold of their farm after it was claimed by the government. Since land seizures began in 2000, thousands of farmers have been forced to abandon their land and flee the country. Others, like Freeth, have refused to move, a stand that has cost some their lives. Correspondent Mike Thomson asked him why he felt the need to write the book. Listen here

Zimbabwean civil society press conference disrupted

del.icio.us TRACK TOP
Thursday, June 9th, 2011 by Bev Clark

Bulawayo Agenda reports that:

Johannesburg – Alleged clashes between ZANU PF and MDC-T activists temporarily disrupted a Zimbabwe Civic Society Press Conference in Sandton’s Devonshire Hotel. Reports are that ten ZANU PF activists swarmed into the press conference venue and ordered people who had gathered to move out. The hotel security personnel managed to quell the noise down so the  press conference could continue. The press conference is being held to brief the media on the Zimbabwe situation. Civic society is gathered in Johannesburg, South Africa ahead of the SADC Extraordinary Summit to discuss the crisis in Zimbabwe. The public media early this week reported that the major parties in the country were all ready to bus supporters to the summit.